All scientific essays undergo a double-blind peer review (both author and referee remain anonymous to one another).

The name of the author will be erased from all essays sent to the referee. The referees’ review will be communicated to the author in a completely anonymous format.

The referees have four possible options for every article:

Can the article be accepted for publication?

• Yes, without revisions
• Yes, with minor revisions
• Yes, with substantial revisions
• No

 

The contents of the review are confidential. Authors submitting their essays for evaluation are prohibited from divulging the results of the peer review.

Referees and the editorial board have a serious and responsible commitment to discretion regarding the author and the scholarly community.